Preliminary, Secondary and Full Compliance: Verify the Decree Definitions
Direct answer: Preliminary, Secondary and Full compliance are the monitoring team’s three cumulative levels, built on paragraph 642 of the Chicago consent decree: a requirement is in policy, relevant personnel are trained, and the requirement is carried out in actual practice. Full compliance alone is not the end point; the Court must later find full and effective compliance. [1][2]
Monitoring reports on the Chicago Police Department consent decree grade each paragraph as being in Preliminary, Secondary and Full compliance, or none of them. This page quotes where those labels come from: paragraph 642 of the decree itself and the Independent Monitoring Team’s written methodology. For how the latest percentages are counted, see how to read Independent Monitoring Report 14. For the separate state rules on officer training, see Illinois police training requirements, and for certificate revocation see automatic versus discretionary decertification.
What the decree itself says (paragraph 642)
The consent decree in Illinois v. Chicago (Case No. 17-cv-6260, filed January 31, 2019) says the Monitor will review or audit whether the City and CPD have substantially complied. It then defines compliance with a requirement as meaning that the City and CPD “(a) have incorporated the requirement into policy; (b) have trained all relevant personnel as necessary to fulfill their responsibilities pursuant to the requirement; and (c) are carrying out the requirement in actual practice.” [1]
The decree text we read does not use the words “Preliminary,” “Secondary” or “Full” in paragraph 642. Those labels are the monitoring team’s way of reporting progress through the three parts of that definition. [1][3]
How the monitor defines Preliminary, Secondary and Full compliance
The monitoring team’s first report (filed November 15, 2019) set out the methodology it says it applies under paragraphs 642, 661 and 662. [3]
| Level | Monitor’s description (summarized, with decree paragraph cited by the monitor) |
|---|---|
| Preliminary | “Refers principally to the development of acceptable policies and procedures that conform to best practices (as defined in ¶730) and to the incorporation of requirements into policy (¶642).” Policies must include enforcement and accountability mechanisms. |
| Secondary | “Refers principally to the development and implementation of acceptable and professional training strategies (¶642)” that convey the policy changes, plus supervisory, managerial and executive practices to implement policies as written. |
| Full | “Refers to adherence to policies within day-to-day operations (¶642).” The monitor looks at whether supervisors notice and correct behavior and whether compliance shows up in routine business documents. |
Counts come from the official source named above and are shown as published. Where a source suppresses small counts, we show 'suppressed', never zero. Differences between groups or places are descriptive and are not a finding about cause or fairness.
Paragraph 730 of the decree defines “best practices” as guidelines, standards, policies, procedures or methods consistent with the decree that are supported by research or empirical evidence or accepted by industry-recognized professionals or organizations. [1]
Independent Monitoring Report 14 (filed October 13, 2026) restates the same three levels in shorter form: whether the City has “(1) created a compliant policy, (2) adequately trained personnel on that policy, and (3) successfully implemented the reform in practice.” [2]
Paragraphs without a policy or training element
Not every paragraph is about a written policy. IMR-14 explains that for such paragraphs the three levels “may follow a different trajectory”: whether the City has established the framework and resources, whether it has effectively communicated the reform to relevant personnel, and whether it has appropriately implemented the reform. [2] The first report gives a training-only example: Preliminary compliance may mean establishing the required training rather than a policy. [3]
The levels are cumulative
IMR-14 states that “compliance levels are cumulative”: every paragraph in Secondary compliance is also counted in the Preliminary total, and every paragraph in Full compliance is counted in both the Preliminary and Secondary totals. [2] That is why, for the 552 original monitorable paragraphs, the report can say at least Preliminary compliance for 546 (about 99%), at least Secondary for 428 (about 78%) and Full for about 188 (about 34%), with 6 paragraphs at no level, as of June 30, 2026. [2] Those percentages use the original monitorable paragraphs as the base; a different base gives different percentages.
Full compliance is not the same as full and effective compliance
- Proof is required. IMR-14 says the City is not in compliance with any requirement until the monitor determines the City has provided sufficient proof. [2] Paragraph 720 of the decree puts the burden on the City to demonstrate full and effective compliance by a preponderance of the evidence. [1]
- Sustainment periods. Paragraph 714 says the decree terminates when the Court finds full and effective compliance maintained for at least one year for Group A sections (Recruitment, Hiring, and Promotions; Training; Officer Wellness and Support) and at least two years for Group B sections (Community Policing; Impartial Policing; Crisis Intervention; Use of Force; Supervision; Accountability and Transparency; Data Collection, Analysis, and Management). [1]
- The Court starts the clock. Under paragraph 715, the Court’s determination of full and effective compliance starts the one- or two-year period. IMR-14 adds that the Court may retroactively set the start of that period when the monitor files a report finding Full compliance. [1][2]
- No numeric threshold. Paragraph 717 says no specific numerical threshold is required, and that temporary or isolated failures, or mere technicalities, do not by themselves defeat full and effective compliance. [1]
How to use these definitions when you read a report
- Find the paragraph number and its level in the report’s section table.
- Ask which part of paragraph 642 is at issue: policy, training, or actual practice.
- Check whether the paragraph has a policy or training element, or follows the alternative trajectory.
- When quoting a percentage, name the base (for example, the original monitorable paragraphs) and the reporting period.
- Remember that “not in compliance” means the monitor has not yet found sufficient proof; it is not a finding of misconduct by anyone.
What we could not confirm
- Whether the methodology has been formally revised since 2019. IMR-14 restates the three levels in shorter form and refers readers to the monitoring team’s website for its assessment process; we did not review those website pages on this date, so we quote the filed reports only.
- How later-added paragraphs (Investigatory Stops, Protective Pat Downs and Loitering) are scored. We did not open the amendment that added them, so we do not describe their base here.
- The filing date of the next monitoring report. IMR-14 says the fifteenth period runs July 1 through December 31, 2026; we did not confirm a due date for that report.
Sources
- Consent Decree, Illinois v. Chicago, No. 17-cv-6260 (N.D. Ill.), Document 703-1, filed January 31, 2019, ¶¶642, 714, 715, 717, 720, 730. cpdmonitoringteam.com (PDF). Read Nov. 20, 2026.
- Independent Monitoring Team, Independent Monitoring Report 14, Document 1392, filed October 13, 2026 (period January 1–June 30, 2026), pages 3–6. cpdmonitoringteam.com (PDF). Read Nov. 20, 2026.
- Independent Monitoring Team, Independent Monitoring Report 1, Document 797, filed November 15, 2019, “Assessing Compliance” section. chicagopoliceconsentdecree.org (PDF). Read Nov. 20, 2026.
Frequently asked questions
What does Preliminary compliance mean in the Chicago consent decree?
The monitoring team says Preliminary compliance refers principally to acceptable policies and procedures that conform to best practices and incorporate the decree’s requirements into policy, citing paragraphs 642 and 730 of the decree.
Are the compliance levels cumulative?
Yes. Independent Monitoring Report 14 states that all paragraphs in Secondary compliance are included in the Preliminary totals, and all paragraphs in Full compliance are included in both the Preliminary and Secondary totals.
Does Full compliance mean the consent decree is over?
No. The decree ends only when the Court finds full and effective compliance and the City maintains it for at least one year (Group A sections) or two years (Group B sections), under paragraphs 714 and 715.
Who has to prove compliance?
Paragraph 720 of the decree says the City bears the burden of demonstrating, by a preponderance of the evidence, that it has achieved full and effective compliance.
More on this topic: Consent-Decree Monitoring · All Standardswise guides · How we research · Affiliate disclosure